Robbie Fowler has named a provocative all-time World Cup XI ahead of the next tournament, packing Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo and Diego Maradona into a three-pronged attack while anchoring defence with John Terry and Rio Ferdinand and midfield with Andrés Iniesta, Dunga and Steven Gerrard — a selection that mixes flair, grit and England-heavy defensive pedigree.
Robbie Fowler’s all-time World Cup XI: the team
Robbie Fowler has set out an 11 that prioritises individual World Cup pedigree and club glory, not pure positional orthodoxy. His final XI reads as follows: Manuel Neuer in goal; a back four of Roberto Carlos, John Terry, Rio Ferdinand and Philipp Lahm; a midfield trio of Dunga, Andrés Iniesta and Steven Gerrard; and an attack of Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo and Diego Maradona.
Formation and balance
Fowler’s selection effectively uses a 4-3-3 framework but accepts stylistic compromises to accommodate generational icons. The spine — Neuer, a defensive pair of Terry and Ferdinand, plus a holding Dunga — is built to allow creative freedom ahead. Including both Messi and Cristiano alongside Maradona forces tactical imagination, but Fowler opts to prioritise star power and World Cup impact over strict positional orthodoxy.
Attack: three all-time greats
Choosing Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo and Diego Maradona together makes a bold statement about modern and historic greatness. Messi’s 2022 World Cup victory and tournament mastery earn him a place; Cristiano’s longevity and Portugal captaincy demand recognition; Maradona’s 1986 performance remains the benchmark for World Cup individual brilliance. Fowler admits the selection strains a conventional system, but it’s clearly intended to assemble the most unignorable attacking trio from World Cup history.
Midfield: creativity, leadership and steel
Andrés Iniesta provides the creative fulcrum, Xavi’s absence replaced by Iniesta’s World Cup-winning influence for Spain. Dunga is the sitting midfielder — a pragmatic choice that offers balance and bite in front of the back four. The late inclusion of Steven Gerrard adds box-to-box energy and leadership, reflecting Fowler’s tendency to favour players with proven tournament mettle and inspirational presence.
Defence and goalkeeper: English centre-back pairing and world-class full-backs
Fowler’s defensive core is strikingly England-heavy. John Terry and Rio Ferdinand are paired centrally for their club-era dominance and reading of the game, while Roberto Carlos and Philipp Lahm provide width, pace and tactical intelligence from full-back positions. Manuel Neuer completes the XI, chosen for his goalkeeping excellence and consistent World Cup performances for Germany.
What these choices reveal
Fowler’s XI prioritises winners and headline-makers. Seven players in his side have lifted the World Cup, underlining a preference for players who delivered on football’s biggest stage. The inclusion of three former England internationals in defence signals a view of English defenders’ competitiveness at the highest level, even if some will call that conservative. Dropping Brazilian Ronaldo (R9) in favour of Gerrard was a late pivot that illustrates Fowler’s balancing act between iconic forwards and midfield leadership.
Why it matters
This lineup sparks discussion about how to evaluate World Cup greatness: pure peak performance (Maradona, 1986), tournament-defining leadership (Neuer, Dunga), sustained elite production (Messi, Cristiano) or influence across club and country (Terry, Ferdinand). It’s a reminder that all-time XIs often reflect personal values — flair versus grit, trophy cabinets versus moments of magic.
Controversies and likely pushback
The team will invite debate. Omitting Brazil’s R9 in the final version will frustrate many who view his World Cup goals and skill as non-negotiable. Likewise, fitting four attacking superstars into a three-man front line is a challenge: tactical purists will question how a manager truly deploys Messi, Ronaldo and Maradona simultaneously. Fowler’s choices favour narrative and nostalgia as much as tactical coherence.
Bottom line
Fowler’s all-time World Cup XI reads as a personality-driven selection — a mix of unquestionable legends and pragmatic picks designed to make headlines and provoke conversation.
Argentina faces off against Iceland
It’s a credible, combustible blend that highlights the enduring debate in football: how do you weigh individual brilliance against tournament-winning utility? For fans and analysts, that argument is exactly the point.
Mail Online
